A psychologist conducts a research project to identify the factors involved in
the formation of teeenagers’ personal identity. How might the researcher best
structure the experiment to study the influence of reference groups on the
participants?
A) Providing a list of groups and organizations and asking participants to circle
the ones whose values they consider to be important
B) Discuss the social circles that study participants spend the most time with,
and why they make those decisions
C) Ask the participants to make split-second judgments about various racial
groups on the basis of photos
D) Obtain detailed histories related to participants’ past mental and physical
health conditions and how that has shaped their personality
Correct answer is A
Identity formation is a complex, multifactorial process that can be influenced by
a number of forces, such as one’s own beliefs, interactions with others, and the
broader culture and society at large. Reference groups are one of these forces, and
refer to the groups of people (whether they be sports teams, groups of friends at
work or school, family groups, cultural or religious groups, a group of famous pop
stars, or any other collection of people) that serve as a reference-point where an
individual’s identity is concerned. In other words, an individual forms, understands,
and develops his or her self-identity in reference to or in comparison to a particular
reference group. For example, a particular person might have a sense of being smart
or accomplished in comparison to a group of their peers at school, or a person
may develop a sense of morality in reference to the virtues promulgated by their
religious leaders.
Answer A is correct because this answer is the best option presented if the goal is
to determine not only which reference groups are important to the participants, but
also which reference groups truly influence those participants. Although there may
be reference groups that have values a person does not consider to be important,
identifying “important values” is the best surrogate marker for determining which
groups a person might view themselves in light of or compare themselves to.