Which of the following statements about how genetic and environmental
factors influence behavior is incorrect?
A) Twin studies allow researchers to differentiate the impact of parental
influences from environmental factors when it comes to their effects on
behavior
B) Traits and behaviors that promote adaptation tend to be selected for in the
process of natural evolution
C) Epigenetics are a powerful influence in the determination of how and when
inherited genetic material is expressed
D) The heritability estimate of 1.0 indicates a negligible impact of
environmental factors upon behavior
Answer A is correct
Twin studies are experiments in which identical twins (two individuals with the exact
same genetic makeup) are raised in different environments and under different parental
influences, then studied to evaluate how different “nurture” conditions influenced
them. The main benefit of twin studies is found in the fact that the “nature” conditions
(e.g. the genetic predispositions of the participants) can be assumed to be the same.
Twin studies are not meant to differentiate the impact of parental influences from
environmental factors, as parental influences and environmental factors are closely
linked and are not separated out in twin studies. Instead, twin studies are meant to
separate the combined influences of parental and environmental factors from genetic
ones as a means of exploring the “nature vs. nurture” controversy–in other words, how
much of a person’s behavior can be attributed to nature (or genes), and how much can
be attributed to nurture (which includes both parental influences and environmental
factors). For this reason, Answer A is correct.